Hi!
I wanted to know how to incorporate SIX SIGMA AS A PART OF HR.
Please do help by sending in links, presentation or any other material that you may have.
Thank You.
Regards,
Shyamali
(I 've already posted this query elsewhere under a wrong section. Kindly ignore my ignorance as im new to this site)

From India, Nasik
Hi Shyamali,

I am giving you some information regarding SIX SIGMA & HR and how to correlate them.Hopefully it would be useful to you.It was a collected article.



What on earth has Six Sigma got to do with HR?


Six Sigma is synonymous with good HR practice in a number of well-known companies. In the first of a two-part article, Paul Carey demystifies the concept of Six Sigma and examines its practice in relation to HR

Many HR professionals would have a good understanding of what Six Sigma is, and some would have first-hand experience with Six Sigma implementation. However, it’s critical to explore what value HR can add to a Six Sigma initiative. Some people believe that Six Sigma is all about widgets and factories, however it’s really about people collaborating and fixing/improving the right things for the best business outcomes.

The term ‘Six Sigma’ is derived from the statistics of variation. In practical terms it’s often applied to errors or defects. A Six Sigma chance of the customer having cause for complaint is three in a million. Or the chance of a part in a motor car failing is three in a million.

What is Six Sigma?

Six Sigma is both a philosophy and a methodology. It’s about improving the experience of customers, improving work experience for the people and improving business outcomes. Done well and widely, Six Sigma can dramatically and often radically change the culture. It is not about training masses of people and hoping for the best.

Six Sigma initiatives within organisations are results oriented. They work on process problems which are critical to the customers, to the staff or to the business. Internal people are thoroughly trained to lead those projects through to successful completion, using a wide range of both statistical and problem analysis tools. The payoff to the business is usually calculated using strict financial criteria. The people who organise and carry out this work are central to the success of the initiative. Knowledge (methodology) is transferred, applied and retained in the organisation by working on business critical issues.

The deployment of Six Sigma in an organisation is in response to a specific need, such as a loss of customers due to unacceptable product or service ‘experience’ in dealing with the firm, or a need to establish a collaborative culture of action. Different needs will result in different deployments for Six Sigma – breadth, speed of deployment and specific Six Sigma methodology application can all vary. The critical message is that there is not a ‘cookie cutter’way to introduce Six Sigma to an organisation, but HR is a key participant both in the decision to deploy and in the design.

Six Sigma roles

In a full Six Sigma project a number of roles are created and filled.

Six Sigma leaders are those senior managers who take on the responsibility for the Six Sigma initiatives (or campaigns, in Motorola language), whereas the CEO or other executive team members may act as sponsor of the whole concept. The leaders seek out and nominate ‘mission-critical projects’, and they provide the management energy and horsepower to free up resources, provide the means and integrate the Six Sigma effort into the organisational big picture. The other senior management player is the project champion – the manager who carries overall departmental or functional responsibility for the particular project, and in many cases is accountable for the project outcomes.

Traditional roles within a Six Sigma deployment include ‘Master Black Belt’, ‘Black Belt’ and ‘Green Belt’, although some companies establish their own nomenclature for these roles.

Master Black Belts are those who technically and organisationally manage and mentor the project leaders, called Black Belts. The Black Belts are the engine room of the initiative, as successful projects breed more success, enhance the reputation of the initiative and consequently lead to organisational improvement. Black Belts are usually full-time for 12–18 months, delivering between two and four projects.

Green Belts provide technical support and data gathering, often in turn leading small but still critical sub-projects as part of a wider project. They are sometimes only involved on a part-time basis.

From these brief descriptions it can be seen that well trained and motivated leaders within the Six Sigma initiative are vital. Six Sigma is all about people and outcomes. HR professionals are usually charged with accountability for the ‘right people in the right role at the right time and at the right cost’ as their organisation strategically matures through marketplace or policy environment twists and turns. The challenge over the last ten years has been for HR professionals to extend their knowledge and expertise to the recruitment, selection, career development, training and evaluation of the new breed of players on the organisational block.

A lens to spot talent and magnify the leadership experience

Six Sigma project leadership roles provide accelerated opportunities for an organisation’s future leaders, according to consultants in the Six Sigma business. Simon Wandke, a partner in Destra Consulting, which counts companies such as BHP Billiton and Telstra among its clients, says potential future leaders get to work on important business issues and fix them, with high visibility to senior management. When HR is not involved from the start of Six Sigma, or merely pays lip service, there’s a risk of parallel leadership and talent development. Early integration of HR systems and structures with the Six Sigma deployment are vital, he believes.

Whenever the high potential talent pool and the Six Sigma talent pool are seen as separate, then they’re in competition. One scavenges from the other for either orthodox leadership positions in the organisation or for Six Sigma project leaders. When the two pools substantially overlap, as they do when HR supports the Six Sigma processes, the overlap supplies synergy. New opportunities within Six Sigma open up for the high potentials, and some people chosen with Six Sigma criteria in mind suddenly reveal themselves as true high potential candidates for future leadership positions. The Six Sigma projects also give these potential leaders opportunities to showcase their talents. The Six Sigma projects test the Black Belts’mettle. Most are enhanced by the experience, but the occasional leadership hopeful falls by the wayside.

Corporate strategy, HR strategy and Six Sigma are one

According to Wandke and Garth Rymer, <ST1 laceName w:st="on">Motorola</ST1 laceName> <ST1 laceType w:st="on">University</ST1 laceType>’s representative in Australia, the most successful and long-lived Six Sigma implementations (GE, Dow Chemical and Motorola are in their second or third decade of Six Sigma) have the upfront involvement and active participation of the finance and HR functions. HR is centrally involved in Six Sigma people policy development, then in the selection, recruitment, training, mentoring and development of these key people.

The development of policy for Six Sigma is a subset of the development of policy for the organisation as a whole. Thus prior to Six Sigma launch, there are role profiles for the key players, key criteria identification and assessment methods for choosing the best people to fit those roles. Performance reviews for Six Sigma leaders are integrated with performance reviews for managers in the mainstream.

In the best firms there is what Wandke calls a ‘backfilling policy’, whereby the career plan for a Six Sigma ‘graduate’ extends to reintegration into the mainstream with sufficiently challenging and engaging assignments. Wandke also stresses the need for planned incentives to take on Six Sigma roles in organisations new to Six Sigma. A prospective Black Belt has to weigh up their career prospects with a known and predictable journey through the organisational mainstream, versus an unknown and unpredictable journey through the uncharted waters of Six Sigma. Again the best firms provide reassurance and social and financial ‘parachutes’ to allow the prospective Black Belt as much certainty as is possible under these unfamiliar conditions. Rymer stresses that one of the prime incentives to the high achievers is an initial challenging, mission-critical project – perhaps something they’ve wanted to sink their teeth into for some time.

Where HR may be frozen out or unwilling

Occasionally HR people who wish to become involved find themselves consciously or unconsciously ‘frozen out’ of Six Sigma initiatives. This can occur when a very strong-minded Six Sigma sponsor manages operations. This is sometimes found in operational or manufacturing environments, where the general or divisional manager onsite does their own thing, trampling over the support functions as they raid the best people for the Six Sigma projects.

Under such conditions, there is a risk of tinkering with both financial and HR systems, and taking shortcuts which will come back to haunt the organisation. Consequently, there is a need – if not an imperative – for HR to muscle into operational territory or try to influence the consultants to make sure proper HR processes are followed. This is to ensure that the bigger career and developmental picture, beyond the day-to-day requirements of the Six Sigma projects, is taken into account.

There are HR people who are unwilling to be part of Six Sigma, Wandke and Rymer have found. Both stress that these negative HR attitudes must change in order for success to prevail. Rymer believes that although some HR individuals may be personally at fault, some may be victims of ‘the Sir Humphrey syndrome’, which refers to organisational cultures which are driven by politics rather than by data and facts. Such cultures militate against smooth implementations of Six Sigma, and they straddle both the public and the private sectors.

In principle, HR represents the people outcomes of a three-legged stool with legs labelled ‘business outcomes’, ‘customer outcomes’ and ‘people outcomes’. HR is a foundation stone, far beyond a simple facilitator or enabler, Wandke believes. Key HR players are included in Six Sigma sessions which are part educative and part introspection. Participants are urged to be inquisitive, both about Six Sigma and their own mindset. They are asked to ask themselves: “Where do I stand on this initiative? Why am I passive? Why am I afraid? What do I see as the risks for me and my department? What are the rational arguments against becoming involved? What could we achieve as an organisation if HR was integrally involved from the inception of the Six Sigma launch?”

A case study in Six Sigma leadership

When prospective Black Belts were called for in a new Six Sigma initiative on one of a mining organisation’s processing sites, the CFO put forward Josie, a young accountant untried in the tough world of the plant. In checking the fit between her capacities and the Black Belt role, it was found that she excelled in the areas of problem analysis, creative thinking and decision making – all the intellectual requirements for the role. She didn’t have a formal statistical background nor did she have a lot of technical knowledge, but she was bright and she would learn.

With the three qualities required for implementation – achievement motivation, resilience and sensitivity to relationships, Josie really shone. Her boss had faith in her, but her light was hidden under a bushel, buried in finance.

Josie’s aptitude for the Black Belt role showed up in the first project, working with people who had a reputation for putting competent female superintendents under a lot of subtle and sometimes unsubtle pressure. But after an initial testing time, Josie was able get through to the people and the people were able to break the back of the problem. She made sure that they got the credit for what they had achieved, and their success became her success, as she progressed to other technically-based projects – originally seen as out of her domain and reach.



The key to success in Six Sigma is having ‘the right people in the right projects’. Where HR is on board early and playing its strategic role in a Six Sigma initiative, one of HR’s key roles is to assess and select the people who will be right for these projects.

HR can act as a powerful ally in persuading managers to part with some of their most prized talent for the 18 months or two years required for the Black Belt role, according to Garth Rymer, <ST1 laceName w:st="on">Motorola</ST1 laceName> <ST1 laceType w:st="on">University</ST1 laceType>’s representative in Australia. “Some managers, even when they have agreed to let the employee go, demand 90 per cent of their time in their old function, while the Six Sigma initiative needs 90 per cent of their time on a crucial project.”HR interventions to resolve this impasse are vital and can help the employee emerge without appearing to desert the manager or pay lip service to the project.

Meredith Doig, managing director of Potentia Australia, has had experience in a large mining organisation in assessing the roles of Black Belts and then profiling the prospective candidates. Although her normal clientele are senior managers in large organisations, this initial contact with Six Sigma led her to further develop the Potentia system in Six Sigma roles. In the mining company she used this system to profile about half the selected Black Belts, while the other half were selected by the site managers using the ‘I like the cut of their jib’ method. After two years of implementation, it emerged that the two least effective Black Belts had been chosen by the site manager and the two most effective had been identified as high potential in the Potentia framework. In particular, one was a ‘sleeper’– an accountant from the finance function at one of the sites (see last issue).

HR setting an example

It would also seem that in some of the best Six Sigma installations, HR sets an example by providing challenging projects within its own sphere of influence. Rymer cites the case of Motorola, who have rigorously attributed resignations within three months of hire to the selection process. They are counted, not entirely fairly, as selection ‘defects’. But Motorola’s HR, driven by data, has grasped this particular nettle and strenuously overhauled its selection practices with a consequent and continuing reduction in this category of resignations.

Some typical projects within HR include modelling the hire versus overtime dilemma. This is done by balancing the cost of entry point wages and salaries and the cost of induction and learning, against the cost of overtime, taking into account burnout, fatigue and additional allowances and breaks. Cross-functional mapping of various HR processes is often a precursor to improvements in those processes, with single-point data entry, elimination of redundant tasks and automation of some of the more tedious and time consuming work. People working in Six Sigma commonly quote the hiring process as one with rich rewards for mapping, understanding, reengineering and streamlining, rewarding both the people being hired and the organisation. The point is, HR can demonstrate their commitment to the organisation behaviourally, both as a supplier and as a lead function in the implementation.

HR as cultural and social change specialists

HR is often at its most effective as a function in deploying its skills in facilitating and monitoring change – especially where the change is to the prevailing culture. Experienced HR change agents are invited on board early as part of what seems to be technical change and subsequently ride shotgun over the accompanying social and cultural changes as they occur. Such events where HR typically helps smooth the impact on the people involved include plant and office closures, new business start-ups, ‘big bang’ERP installations, restructures and so on. They bring this expertise to Six Sigma projects, some of which can potentially have the same degree of social impact as the examples just cited. And Six Sigma is a new culture and way of behaving; a mindset based on facts and data.

HR as facilitators for re-entry of key Six Sigma roles

Prising talent loose from their old roles is the reverse of HR’s role in facilitating re-entry into either the old role or a new mainstream role. HR also has a role in assuring that the Black Belts continue to be challenged by the projects which succeed the first one, as this is one of the most common reasons that Black Belts lose their desire.

The Black and Green Belt market is currently a seller’s market, with the burgeoning of Six Sigma initiatives, and indeed of consulting companies promoting Six Sigma. Thus there is a temptation for some of the organisation’s best people, now tried and tested, to leave the organisation for lucrative consulting positions.

It therefore behoves HR to anticipate this pull on its best talent from the outside, and to provide countermeasures so that the best people stay and continue to grow. A ‘backfilling policy’ cuts in here. A major inducement to stay is challenging assignments in the mainstream. Another consideration is reward and recognition for a job usually well done. Such reward and recognition should occur after each project and at the end of the role. As mentioned previously, performance review systems should be flexible enough to cover Black Belt project work and orthodox functional progress and achievement. As far as possible the newly graduated Black Belt should have at least as much idea of where they might head in the medium-term as their high potential equivalents still in the mainstream, or possibly even more idea, as it is they who have taken the risk, especially in new implementations.

Regards

Kiran.N

From India, Gurgaon
Hi all!
It was good to raise this topic. Even i wanted to know regarding Six Sigma
By reading the detailed reply. I got information regarding the same..This site is really useful and informative
Suchitra.V

From India
Hi Shyamali,
Thats a good idea to incorporate Six Sigma into HR as well. It does not stop with operations or Quality departments alone.
I am forwarding some of the link which were useful to me in gathering some information for Training.
http://www.isixsigma.com/me/dmaic/
http://www.6sigma.us/dmaic-step-zero-leadership.php
http://www.isixsigma.com/
http://www.qualitytimes.co.in/6sigma_dmaic.htm
http://www.sixsigmaqualtec.com/Library/dmaic.html
Hope you find them useful,
Regards,
Mohammed Azmath

From India, Tiruchchirappalli
Community Support and Knowledge-base on business, career and organisational prospects and issues - Register and Log In to CiteHR and post your query, download formats and be part of a fostered community of professionals.







Contact Us Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms Of Service

All rights reserved @ 2024 CiteHR ®

All Copyright And Trademarks in Posts Held By Respective Owners.